Request PDF on ResearchGate | On Aug 20, , Niels de Fine Olivarius and others published The astonishing hypothesis. Review of The Astonishing Hypothesis: The Scientific Search For The Soul by. Francis Crick. Bill Webster. Department of Psychology. Monash. The astonishing hypothesis 5 editions. Conciencia (Psicología), Consciousness, Mente y cuerpo, Mind and body, Neural circuitry, Percepción visual, Visual perception, Protected DAISY. The astonishing hypothesis: the scientific search for the soul.
|Language:||English, Indonesian, Dutch|
|Genre:||Politics & Laws|
|ePub File Size:||15.62 MB|
|PDF File Size:||12.19 MB|
|Distribution:||Free* [*Sign up for free]|
The Astonishing Hypothesis is a book by scientist Francis Crick about consciousness. . Print/export. Create a book · Download as PDF · Printable version. [DOWNLOAD] PDF The Astonishing Hypothesis: The Scientific Search for the Soul by Francis Crick [DOWNLOAD] PDF The Astonishing. [opening paragraph] -- Clark: The `astonishing hypothesis' which you put forward in your book, and which you obviously feel is very controversial, is that `You.
And while there are certainly animal rights activists who might argue we are giving them worse lives than they would have had in the wild, that is really besides the point. The issue isn't about comparing their lives to one without interference.
The issue is whether we have a right, or at least a very good reason, to do harm to sentient life a point which can certainly be argued, but lets agree that animals can feel pain that doesn't make a free choice to put itself in that situation. This is not a black and white question, and it doesn't have an easy answer.
I imagine a comprehensive look at this issue would involve really determining what the animal experiences and what the tests involve, and what the possible benefits of the research are.
It's a mistake to say that all animal research is wrong. It's just as much of a mistake to say that all scientific research is worth while, and that anything done in the pursuit of the research is acceptable.
Crick completely misses the point of this issue. And what's more, his last line about it being a distorted sense of values to treat animals equally can't just be stated as fact.
We know their structure in detail, and most of the laws that control their behavior. Physics has provided a framework of explanation for chemistry. Our detailed knowledge of organic chemical molecules is enormous and expanding every day. Admittedly, we still do not understand exactly what happens at very small distances within the nucleus of an atom , at extremely high energies, and in very large gravitational fields.
But for the conditions we normally have to deal with on earth when an atom will only change into another atom under very special circumstances , most scientists think that this incompleteness of our knowledge probably matters very little, if at all, in our attempts to understand the mind and the brain.
In addition to our knowledge of basic chemistry and physics, the earth sciences such as geology and cosmic science astronomy and cosmology have developed pictures of our world and our universe that are quite different from those common when the traditional religions were founded.
The modern picture of the universe, and how it developed in time, forms an essential background to our present knowledge of biology.
That knowledge has been completely transformed in the last years. Until Charles Darwin and Alfred Wallace independently hit on the basic mechanism driving biological evolution -- the process of natural selection -- the "Argument from Design" appeared to be unanswerable.
How could an organism as complex and well designed as man have arisen without the help of an all-wise Designer? Yet this argument has collapsed completely. We now know that all living things, from bacteria to ourselves, are closely related at the biochemical level.
We know that life has existed on earth for billions of years, and that the many species of plants and animals have changed, often radically, over that time. The dinosaurs have gone and in their place many new species of mammals have arisen.
We can watch the basic processes of evolution happening today, both in the field and in our test tubes.
Find a copy in the library
In this century there has been an equally dramatic biological advance, due to our understanding of the molecular nature of genes, the processes involved in their exact replication, together with our detailed knowledge of proteins and the mechanisms of their synthesis. We now realize that proteins, as a class, are immensely powerful and versatile, and can form the basis of elaborate biochemical devices.
A major assault is being mounted on embryology now often called "developmental biology". The fertilized egg of a sea urchin normally divides many times, eventually turning into a mature sea urchin. If, after the first division, the two daughter cells of the fertilized egg are separated, then each of them will develop, in time, into a separate though rather smaller sea urchin.
A similar experiment can be done on a frog''s egg. The molecules have reorganized themselves to produce two little animals from the material that would otherwise have produced one.
Astonishing Hypothesis: The Scientific Search for the Soul
When this was first discovered, about a hundred years ago, it was suggested that some kind of immaterial Life Force must surely be at work. It seemed inconceivable that this dramatic doubling of a living creature could ever be explained on a biochemical basis -- that is, using the properties of organic and other molecules and their interactions. Nowadays we feel that we shall have no difficulty in principle in working out how this can happen, although we expect the explanation to be complex.
As Lewis Carroll's Alice might have phrased it: Isn't this what reductionist science has always believed? Edit this record.
Mark as duplicate. Find it on Scholar. Request removal from index.
Revision history. Configure custom resolver. On a Confusion About a Function of Consciousness.
More From mesagerdivin17
Ned Block - - Brain and Behavioral Sciences 18 2: Facing Up to the Problem of Consciousness. David J. Chalmers - - Journal of Consciousness Studies 2 3: Eric Schwitzgebel - - Philosophical Studies 7: Two Conceptions of Subjective Experience.
Imaging or Imagining? A Neuroethics Challenge Informed by Genetics. Posing Hypotheses Responsibly in Psychiatry.No Downloads. That knowledge has been completely transformed in the last years. Request removal from index. The first is that many people are reluctant to accept what is often called the "reductionist approach" -- that a complex system can be explained by the behavior of its parts and their interactions with each other.
The astonishing hypothesis : the scientific search for the soul
Published in: In other projects Wikiquote. There are, of course, a few exceptions. First, to understand consciousness either visual or general , we must determine where the cells responsible for determining consciousness are located.